Scoring Extended- and Short-Response Items Extended- and short-response items are evaluated according to an established scoring scale, called a rubric, developed from a combination of expectations and a sample of actual student responses. Such rubrics must be particularized by expected work and further developed by examples of student work in developing a guide for scorers. Illinois educators play a substantial role in developing these guides used for the scoring of the short- and extended-response items. Committees of mathematics educators from throughout the state attend a validation meeting, during which they use the mathematics scoring rubrics to establish task-specific criteria that are used to score all short- and.